FOR SALE
$3,395,000

4540 State Route 28
Old Forge, NY 13420

12
Bedrooms
5
Baths
6,500
Sqft
11.3
Acres
11
Days on Market
4 Cars
Garage
$523
Price Per Sqft.
Request Tour
Book a free private tour instantly.
Schedule Tour

By sending a request you agree to our Privacy Policy & TOS

Property Description

a rare offering on fourth lake - 11 acres and 600' of shoreline. Welcome to Fieldstone Lodge a truly extraordinary opportunity to own one of the largest privately held tracts on Fourth Lake, nestled in the heart of the Fulton Chain of Lakes. Spanning over 11 private acres with 600 feet of shoreline, this exceptional waterfront estate offers a blend of natural beauty, architectural character, investment potential, and unrivaled privacy. The estate comprises thoughtfully designed structures. The Lodge features expansive gathering spaces, soaring ceilings, a striking fieldstone fireplace, five bedrooms, two baths, and multiple sitting areas to comfortably accommodate guests. Natural light floods every room through stylish windows that perfectly frame the surrounding forest and lake. Just steps away across a charming stone courtyard lies the Main House, with floor-to-ceiling lakefront views, wonderful living and dining spaces, a cozy fireplace, five bedrooms, and two newly renovated rustic baths. Two additional inviting cabins provide extra space for guests, creating a perfect compound feel that balances privacy with togetherness. Southwest-facing lakefront ensures abundant afternoon sun, ideal for relaxing on the stone patio, gathering on the large floating dock, or enjoying the shoreline's many peaceful spots. Fourth Lake offers miles of navigable water, part of the historic Fulton Chain, one of the Adirondack Park's most sought-after destinations. Opportunities like Fieldstone Lodge are nearly unheard of. The vast majority of properties on Fourth Lake sit on under 2 acres with 50 to 200 feet of shoreline. Parcels of 5+ acres with waterfront are rare. Anything over 10 acres and 500+ feet of shoreline is virtually nonexistent. Whether you envision a private family retreat, luxury rental compound, or long-term investment, this one-of-a-kind Adirondack estate is simply unmatched in many ways compared to other waterfront properties on Fourth Lake.

4540 State Route 28 is a property for sale for $3,395,000 in Old Forge, NY 13420 and is part of Herkimer County, NY . This home is 6,500 square feet and is located on a 11.3 acre lot and features 12 bedrooms and 5 bathrooms with a 4 car garage.

Listing Provided By: Matthew Ellis, Coldwell Banker Whitbeck Assoc Tupper Lake 5183599440 Source: ACV MLS MLS#: 205125

See More Homes for Sale in...

Property Information
Stories Total
2
View
Lake View, Mountain(s) View, Trees/Woods, Water View
Waterfront Features
Water Front, Water Front
Rooms Total
11
11.3 Acres
Zip Code
13420
Water
Well Water
Lot Features
Sloping, Landscaping, Level Topography, Trees, Great View, Wooded
Other Structures
Barn, Boat House, Carriage House, Outbuilding, Shed
Tax Annual Amount
14663
Road Surface
Paved
Year Built
1893
Road Frontage Type
Public
Roof
Asphalt, Metal Roof
Location Information
State
NY
County
Herkimer County
City
Old Forge
Building Information
12 Bedrooms
5 Full Bathrooms
Living Area
6, 300 sqft
Construction Materials
Frame, Stone Exterior, Wood Siding Exterior
Architectural Style
Adirondack, Camp
Interior Features
Electric Range
Electric Water Heater
Microwave
Refrigerator
2 Fireplaces
Fireplace located in Family Room, Fireplace located in Living Room, Masonry
Security Features
Carbon Monoxide Detector(s), Smoke Detector(s)
Cathedral Ceilings
High Speed Internet
Walk-in Closet(s)
General Information
Total Living Square Footage
6, 500
Exterior Features
Boat Dock
Grill
Lake Access
Lighting
Storage
Patio & Porch Features
Covered, Patio, Porch
Garage & Parking Information
Parking Information
Additional Parking, Circular Driveway, Driveway, Gravel
Utility Information
Heating Type
Fireplace Insert, Fireplace, Forced Air, Gas Heating
Sewer
Septic Tank
Utilities Available
Cable Available, Electricity Connected, High Speed Internet, Phone Available, Propane
Additional Features
Bathroom
8 x 10, Ceramic Tile
Rooms Information
Bathrooms
5
Kitchen
20 x 24, Laminate
Living Room
30 x 18, Natural Woodwork
Dining Room
30 x 12, Natural Woodwork
Bedroom 2
10 x 12, Natural Woodwork
Bedroom 3
14 x 16, Natural Woodwork
Bedroom 4
10 x 12, Natural Woodwork
Bedroom 5
10 x 12, Natural Woodwork
Bathroom 2
8 x 10, Ceramic Tile
Bedroom
14 x 16, Natural Woodwork

Properties Nearby for Sale

4540 State Route 28, Old Forge, NY
For Sale$3.4M

4540 State Route 28
Old Forge, NY

3544 State Route 28, Old Forge, NY
For Sale$300K

3544 State Route 28
Old Forge, NY

599 South Shore Road, Old Forge, NY
For Sale$599.9K

599 South Shore Road
Old Forge, NY

4540 State Route 28
Old Forge, NY
Questions or Interested?
Contact the Agent Now.
Preferred Method of Contact
Contact Agent

By sending a request you agree to our Privacy Policy & TOS

Local Preferred Agent

4540 State Route 28
Old Forge, NY 13420

-
Local Preferred Agent
or
Request Tour
Book a private tour instantly.

By sending a request you agree to our Privacy Policy & TOS

4540 State Route 28 is a property for sale for $3,395,000 in Old Forge, NY 13420 and is part of Herkimer County, NY . This home is 6,500 square feet and is located on a 11.3 acre lot and features 12 bedrooms and 5 bathrooms with a 4 car garage. Nearby schools include , , and . This address can also be written as 4540 State Route 28, Old Forge, NY 13420. This home has been listed on BoldPorch since Jul 03, 2025 BoldPorch last checked and updated this listing on Jul 08, 2025 at 8:32pm UTC .